Hello friends! I have been reading a lot lately and though I totally missed last month, I did not forget and definitely want to tell you what I have been reading for
An Open Book. Hosted by Carolyn Astfalk, this is the new WWRW linkup.
Have I mentioned I joined another book club? It's been really good for me. I can already tell I like the new book club a little better. The books they pick are discussion worthy which is great. I think I am probably going to slowly start breaking up with my original book club. Not right away or anything, but probably by Christmas or early next year.
Okay, so I kind of wrote
here about Orginial Book Club's (OBC) February book which was
The Beekeeper's Apprentice by Laurie King.
It is maybe my favorite Sherlock Holmes continuation I've read. It's smartly written. It has been a long time since I've had to look up definitions while I was reading. Admittedly a lot of the words turned out to be British slang but still.
The plot follows Mary Russell becoming Sherlock Holmes apprentice and them solving crimes. I love a good series and this book is the first of thirteen so that's nice. They are suspenseful but again, it's a series so not
too suspenseful.
Verdict: Definitely Read
OBC's March book turned out to be
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe by C.S. Elliot.
For my 8th birthday my friend Ben Watson got me the Chronicles of Narnia series. I promptly read them. I didn't like them. I hadn't read them since.
I read this one again for book club last Thursday. I still didn't like it. I know that makes me an odd duck in the world but I just don't get it. C.S. Lewis is a beautiful writer but I cannot figure out why this plot and these stories are so enchanting. I mean, I get the Christian allegory (Even though Lewis says it's not so much allegory as it is supposal.) but that's not enough to sway me.
The world of Narnia just doesn't appeal to me I guess. Magical wardrobes taking children to a land with talking animals is just not my thing. I'd rather hear about their lives in the big house waiting our WWII as it happens.
Verdict: You should probably read it if you haven't because it's a classic. You don't have to like it though.
The March book(s) for my New Book Club (NewBC) were To Kill a Mockingbird and Go Set a Watchman by Harper Lee.
You've probably read
Mockingbird before. I don't even feel the need to expound upon it. Because Atticus Finch.
But anyway it was probably a bad idea to read them back to back. If you've been living in the complete dark you probably know the scandal about
Watchman. But just in case: Harper Lee wrote Watchman first and never wanted it published. Then she got dementia and her sister ran her estate. When her sister passed away, suddenly, after years of saying no, Lee signed the papers that
Watchman could be published.
Even under these very fishy circumstances I was still wanting to read it because adult Scout and Atticus Finch sounds fascinating. I admit, now after reading it, I wish I just left it alone. First off, the Atticus we all know and love is radically different, which was actually fascinating. Not that I particularly love this older Atticus but since he regularly wins "Best Fictional Father" awards it was kind of nice to see that he is in fact human. (Not that I agree with his personal stances.)
But that is about the best I can say about it. The book reads like a rough draft and it is certainly clear why Lee never actually wanted it published. Not only does it undermine
Mockingbird but it is not an easy read. Fragments and run-ons and thoughts not fleshed out entirely make up a good solid portion of the book. It is a hard read in many ways.
Verdict: If you didn't read Mockingbird for school at some point or since you should get on that. It's an American legend for a reason. As for Watchman, definitely not worth purchasing. Could potentially be an interesting read but proceed with caution. You cannot unread it. Consider reading the spoilers even.
This afternoon I read the book that NewBC will be discussing on Sunday evening.
The Thing About Jellyfish by Ali Benjamin.
The book follows Suzy as she grieves the loss of her long time best friend who drown even though she was a good swimmer. Suzy becomes convinced that it was actually a rare Jellyfish sting because things don't happen without a reason. Throughout the book we get in depth with Suzy while we discover that her friendship had grown complicated in the way that middle school friendships can be,
When I started reading this book, which is geared for young adults I was rolling my eyes. Suzy is written very complicated and it was hard to read at the start. There are reflections of the past in italics and she is very smart and thinks very fast. Also Benjamin definitely pushes a fair amount of liberal ideas at the beginning. I even began Kindle highlighting the biggies. A supporting character is written as gay even though his sexuality doesn't influence the plot at all, lots of references to the save the planet movement etc.
But as I got into the book and started to really understand Suzy, her friendship history with Franny, and her grief, it was actually a really beautiful story. I wish I hadn't felt the need to eye roll at the start because the deep heartfelt emotions I felt in the middle and the end were intense. Everything that she experiences was raw and real. It brought tears to my eyes and an ache in my awkward-middle school self's heart.
The ending was bright without being too unbelievable. It was good. I was really not expecting it to be. I wanted to hate it. But I didn't. It was solid.
Verdict: I don't know that I would let my 12-year-old read this book but at the same time I would want her to. Definitely a book I am glad to have read as an adult. If M was older and the right age, I would maybe do a "read together at the same time" kind of thing so we could discuss it. There's a lot of openings for some heart-to-heart communication here.
These aren't the only things I've read this past month but they are the ones worth talking about right now. I am linking up with An Open Book and I hope you'll go over and see what other's have been reading lately.