Dear ABC Family,
I don't even know what to say about your decision to cancel
Bunheads.
I am sad that you got rid of a show written by my all time favorite Amy Sherman-Palladino. I admit, when the show first started I was hesitant. I was. You see,
Gilmore Girls is my all time favorite show and I didn't know if I had room in my heart. But the heart is a muscle and therefore able to expand and I made room for my new favorite show.
Why you thought
Secret Life of the American Teenager was worthy of 5 seasons and
Bunheads only got 18 episodes is beyond my comprehension. But then again, I am not your target demographic. What it really comes down to is that
Bunheads is too good for your channel. It is smart. And real. And actually fairly well acted. Plus it doesn't employ the use of stupid comedy to be funny. Compared to some of the gems of programming you produce. Or it didn't. Because you canceled it. It's done. To forever remain 18 episodes which seriously, you had better at least put out on DVD.
I am sorry that AS-P didn't give you
Glee but that's a stupid show too, maybe FOX will buy Bunheads and you can trade?! I
wish another network would pick it up but I think
Bunheads will forever be lost to a land with
Freaks and Geeks and other one season wonders. I take the fact that the show was in limbo for so long to actually be a good sign, it means it didn't go down without a fight. That's good. It shouldn't have. You killed a winning combination. And all the good things it had going for it.
Amy Sherman-Palladino is one of the only writers I know who writes smart, fast and honest.
Bunheads was witty, funny and full of references that made you think. Big words, real moments--it was incredibly true to life. I mean, yes the teenage girl getting her own perfectly designed apartment on her own is a little far fetched but as I have already alluded to some of your other programming has ridiculous elements in spades. For goodness sakes, one show is called
Switched At Birth.
Sutton Foster, that quirky wonderful actress. Breaking out from Broadway was good for her. She's pretty without being Hollywood pretty and she was the perfect Michelle. Michelle was the kind of character teenaged shows need more of. Teenagers need coaches and role models that they can honestly speak to and learn from. Did Michelle have flaws? Yeah, absolutely, but that's what kept her honest and interesting.
It is a shame that television has no more Kelly Bishop. To chuck an American Gem of her magnitude out the window, man I hope you live to regret that. She was perfect. Now I loved her Emily Gilmore, she was amazing. But the way she matched the cadence of Foster was breath taking--there was never a boring moment when she was on the screen. She acts with every bone and breath, and better yet, she reacts with her soul.
Teenaged girls in real friendships and relationships. They weren't fighting over clothes, liars and gossip. If you can find a show about a group of girls that more accurately portrays teenagers let me know, I'd watch it. They didn't have perfect makeup. They worried about normal issues, not just break ups and intimacy but spiders, new kids and being forced to wear ugly dresses at their father's second weddings. They forgot promises and made them up, they had sleepovers and discussed books. I'm not saying these girls were Saints, but that only made them more real.
I don't know why you made the choice you did. I can't say I wasn't expecting it as I will say it again,
this show was too good for your channel.
Nevertheless, I am sad. Good luck in the future stumbling upon anything with even a smidgen of substance.
With deepest regrets because I wish I was writing a thank you for renewing letter,
Madeline